Dropdown for unpopular comics

DoneDirtCheap · Post by **DoneDirtCheap** » Sun Sep 08, 2002 11:11 am

Can people be kicked out of dropdowns?
There are some decidedly popular folks on the keenlosers dropdown. I mean, c'mon - BoxJam's doodle? In the world of webcomics, he's roughly as unpopular as Mark Wahlberg.

Just sayin'

Okk · Post by **Okk** » Sun Sep 08, 2002 11:14 am

Who's Mark Wahlberg?

DoneDirtCheap · Post by **DoneDirtCheap** » Mon Sep 09, 2002 8:13 am

Mark Wahlberg is Marky Mark, of funky bunch fame
He's recently switched over from producing bad music to doing mediocre, yet cute, acting.
He's not uber-famous, but he's not unknown. Thus the comparison to boxjam's doodle. A fair number of people read boxjam on a daily basis. If you don't wanna do the gruntwork of checking every single link in the menu, I could do that and provide a list of those comics that are dead, and those that are far too alive, to be on the losers dropdown.
I mean, I've looked at a couple, and they don't even have the dropdown on their site anywhere anymore.

DDC

Randomaxe · Post by **Randomaxe** » Mon Sep 09, 2002 8:32 am

Okay, so what constitutes "unpopular"? I mean, my comic constitutes about 0.09% of Keenspace's traffic, which doesn't seem like much... is it an "unpopular" comic?

DoneDirtCheap · Post by **DoneDirtCheap** » Mon Sep 09, 2002 6:31 pm

Well, I guess any sort of cut-off has to be ultimately arbitrary. Does 50 regular readers sound reasonable to anyone? That is: once your site logs are showing a consistent update-day average of, say, 75 or so visits (as opposed to hits), you've probably got at least 50 regular readers. I don't think you're a loser any more at that point. Maybe not a winner, but definitely not a loser.

JesterAG · Post by **JesterAG** » Wed Sep 11, 2002 10:42 am

But, if all of these comics are unpopular, how will word get out, Hmmm? :p

Adventures in the Real World
http://aitrw.keenspace.com/news.htm
Al Gonzalez III

Let us all band together to create much popularity and happy days for us all!

Okk · Post by **Okk** » Thu Sep 12, 2002 10:00 am

DoneDirtCheap wrote:once your site logs are showing a consistent update-day average of, say, 75 or so visits (as opposed to hits), you've probably got at least 50 regular readers.

Well, hang on.. What about the non-update-days? Supposing a comic is updated one day every week, but the daily visits are relatively consistant throughout the week? (I dunno.. maybe the readers don't use calendars or something..) I think this might be a bit more difficult to determine than you originally anticipated.. Non-update-days should be taken into consideration, but what about outliers? Say a person has a consistent update-day average of 75.. then one update-day they get 1 visit. What do we make of that? Additionally, there is no single aspect of the weblogs that is perfectly accurate. Although visits may be considered "most accurate" I have friends who have figured out how to mess with that figure as well. The other figures (Hits, KBytes, Pages, Files) should be taken into account too. My hits are deceptively high, because they go up everytime someone sees this dropdown. If we factor in daily and hourly statistics, as well as the individual hostnames responsible for them, the equasion could become really really big!

Okk · Post by **Okk** » Thu Sep 12, 2002 10:01 am

We should also find a way to work search strings into it.. I like search strings...

DoneDirtCheap · Post by **DoneDirtCheap** » Fri Sep 13, 2002 12:05 pm

Jester: the gnomes, of course.
Although that's actually a straw man. All the popular people remove this dropdown from their front site.

Okk: you're making it more complicated than it is. We don't actually need an accurate count of regular readers. All we need is a criteria which, when met, indicates that the person has a decent-sized population of regular readers. if you have a consistent update-day average of 75 visits, then you've probably got at least 50 readers. If you've got more, then you've got more, good for you. If you get an update day with only one visit, then, well, it's not consistent, is it?

The search string will be, of course "britney underaged hot newt college thermos".

Okk · Post by **Okk** » Mon Sep 16, 2002 2:27 pm

I have a feeling that's an actual search string from your logs.

Anyway, I'll think about criteria, maybe, and send out my black ops agents to weed out the populars. I would like to know who's on the dropdown, but does not have the dropdown on their site.. but I'm too busy and/or lazy to look into that for myself.

DoneDirtCheap · Post by **DoneDirtCheap** » Tue Sep 17, 2002 8:59 pm

*sniff*
I don't actually have any search-engine referrals yet. :/

Right on for the black ops guys. Do it for uncle Sam, boys.

And if I haven't yet said so already (to lazy to check): thanks for being an active maintainer of your dropdown.

Okk · Post by **Okk** » Thu Sep 19, 2002 11:11 am

Aww, come on. I'm a busy guy. I'm a full time college student with two (or something) online comics that won't draw themselves... I maintain this dropdown... by adding new members sometimes... but sometimes I have trouble finding their email addresses so I can inform them of their addition. That always sucks.. Also, I haven't beaten FF Tactics yet. And I have the gall to call myself a Squarehead?

hmm.. maybe i should be doing homework or something...

Eyulra · Post by **Eyulra** » Fri Sep 20, 2002 11:15 am

Um I was curious if I could join the dropdown? Or are you not taking anymore people?

BlurryMystr · Post by **BlurryMystr** » Sun Sep 22, 2002 1:10 pm

If you're still taking on applicants, consider this my applicable application.

No 4th Wall to Break! http://no4thwalltobreak.keenspace.com

DoneDirtCheap · Post by **DoneDirtCheap** » Sun Sep 22, 2002 3:22 pm

Naw, I wasn't kidding - that was an honest and entirely unsarcastic "thank you".

Homework is for losers.

ZOMBIE USER 11784 · Post by **ZOMBIE USER 11784** » Tue Sep 24, 2002 5:27 am

Here, take this one

Gameshow
http://gameshow.keenspace.com
and you can call me Nike Young

Advertisingbear · Post by **Advertisingbear** » Tue Sep 24, 2002 3:08 pm

this is a great idea man. thanks!

Advertising Bear
http://advertisingbear.keenspace.com
Pete

peace,
Pete

JGPocky · Post by **JGPocky** » Tue Sep 24, 2002 8:06 pm

I'd like to try to get more people reading my comic.
The thing with words and pictures is called Dueling Planets.
That thing is located at dupla.keenspace.com.
My name happens to be Jacob Grove.

Booga booga.

JG!

Rahs · Post by **Rahs** » Fri Sep 27, 2002 1:11 pm

Comic name: RAHS
URL: http://rahs.keenspace.com
Authors: Jaws and Scary Lady

Thanks

Okk · Post by **Okk** » Fri Oct 11, 2002 4:56 pm

guess i should probably update this thing...

Comic Genesis Forums

Dropdown for unpopular comics

What?

Sign me up!

(x - q) / fmv = Loser

(equasion) + string = Loser

Huh?

Destroy all of civilization

Question

I'm a loser, too

Losers R me?

umm... oh yeah.....