Stump that artist VI: Stump Hard ***THE END***

[IVstudios]

For the new entrees:
First one looks like SteveRules.
Second one looks like McD again.

[McDuffies]

I went ahead and added another new entry, even though it's few days before the deadline, but what the heck.

[LibertyCabbage]

#10: Cope
#11: McDuffies
#12: Cap'n Claude

[CaptainClaude]

I DID ALL OF THEM.

Did I just spoil it for everyone?

[McDuffies]

"Alas, mcDuffies then appeared with the list of actual participants."

eve
Ivstudios
kwill
liberty cabbage
Maria and Michelle
mcDuffies
pimpette
wendybird

[CaptainClaude]

I'd call that good timing.

[Killbert-Robby]

In order of how they show up on the PB

1-Eve
2-IV
3-McD
4-LC
5-M&M
6-IV
7-Kwill
8-Eve
9-Pimpy
10-Uhhh I'll just say Pimpy again
11-KWill
12-Wendy

[MariaAndMichelle]

1: mcDuffies
2: IV
3: KWill
4: Pimpette
5: Eve
6: IV
7: LibertyCabbage
8: Pimpette
9: Wendy
10: LibertyCabbage
11: mcDuffies
12: Wendy

...These are probably all wrong.

[Robin Pierce]

In order of how they show up on the PB

1-Eve
2-IV
3-McD
4-LC
5-M&M
6-IV
7-Claude
8-Eve
9-Pimpy
10-Uhhh I'll just say Pimpy again
11-KWill
12-Wendy

Notice how claude wasn't on the list of participants?

[Killbert-Robby]

Aw shit you're right, Claude was my guess before the participant list, so I got muddled while I was writing it all out again <_<
*goes and fixes it*
FIXED

[Wendybird]

All right, here's another round of questionable guesses and lies:

1 eve
2 iv
3 iv
4 lc
5 pimpette
6 pimpette
7 kwill
8 m&m
9 mcduffies
10 m&m
11 mcduffies
12 kwill

[CaptainClaude]

I'm not on the list but i still did them all, i just dont want credit.

[IVstudios]

Second Guesses:
1. Eve Z
2. Kwill
3. Kwill
4. LC
5. Eve Z
6. Pimpette
7. LC
8. M&M
9. McD
10. WendyBird
11. McD
12. Pimpette

[Wendybird]

Oh, see, now I'm in a logic knot. IV guessed Kwill for the two that I guessed were IV. Either he threw his guess of Kwill to confuse everyone (yeah, right) or one of my guesses is wrong. So 2 now goes to Pimpette and 5 reverts to LC.

This is so confusing!!

[McDuffies]

As you wish, but it could be a red herring, how else would he not give himself away.
Votes that you give to your own entries, of course, don't count.

[LibertyCabbage]

2nd guesses...

#1: Eve Z
#2: IVStudios
#3: KWill
#4: Pimpette
#5: Eve Z
#6: IVStudios
#7: KWill
#8: Wendybird
#9: McDuffies
#10: M&M
#11: McDuffies
#12: Pimpette

[McDuffies]

Dudum! Results:

1. Eve
2. IVstudios
3. Kwill
4. Liberty Cabbage
5. Wendybird
6. IVstudios
7. mcDuffies
8. Wendybird
9. mcDuffies
10. Pimpette
11. Kwill
12. Maria and Michelle

[KWill]

Dudum! Results:
...
2. IVstudios
...
6. IVstudios
...

...
2. IV studios. The digital style of lines is similar to what he usually does, plus there's stuff I'll be explaining later on.
...
6. IV studios. As with 2, except this one is his style. If he hadn't used the same beige and orange tone for the second one, I'd be less convinced. Even if it wasn't him, I'm certain that 2 and 6 are done by the same person.
...

Ahahaha! Not even your tricksy use of different file types could fool me! >=D

[McDuffies]

Here are tables:

First round:

Code: Select all

    Wendy  Iv  LC  Kwill Robby Dream
1.  y      y   y   y/n
2.  n      h   y   y
3.  n      n   y   x	
4.  n      y   x   n
5.  x      n   n   n
6.  n      x   y   y     y
7.  n      n   n   n           n
8.  x      y   y   x
9.  n      y   y   y
10.        n   n
11.        n   n
12.            n

Second Round

Code: Select all

    Robby m&m Wendy   IV  LC
1.  y     n   y       y   y
2.  y     y   y to n  x   y
3.  n     y   n       y   y
4.  y     n   y       y   x
5.  n     n   x       n   n
6.  y     y   n       x   y
7.  n     n   n       n   n
8.  n     n   x       n   y
9.  n     n   y       y   y
10. y     n   n       n   n
11. y     n   n       n   n
12. n     x   n       n   n

First round:
Wendy had 1 hit and 6 misses, though if we shifted her guesses by one, she's fare much better
Iv scored decent with 4 hits and 5 misses
Kwill had 3.5 hits 3.5 misses - 0.5 being that he was indecisive about one, no it wasn't Buster
Robby tried for one entry and guessed correct, while Dreammaniac went for one and missed

I declare LC as a winner of this round with 6 hits 5 misses. While he had as much misses as IV, he had more hits. Entries I added later confused him a bit, while he had 6:2 rate with original nine.

Second Round:
Maria and Michelle had 3 hits and 8 misses
Wendy improves with 4 hits and 6 misses, but then she changed one vote and decreased number of hits to 3
Iv didn't manage to get better result with 4 hits and 6 misses

Robby fares well with 6 hits 6 misses and almost ties with
LC who has 6 hits and 5 misses (difference between the two being that his entry is discarded) playing safe and not changing his votes significantly.

***
Now, entries:

Code: Select all

		First        second
		yes  no      yes     no
1. Eve	        3.5  0.5     4       1
2. IVstudios    2    1       4 to 3  0 to 1
3. Kwill        1    2       3       2
4. Liberty      1    2       3       1
5. Wendybird    0    3       0       4
6. IVstudios    3    1       3       1
7. mcDuff       0    4       0       5
8. Wendybird    2    0       1       3
9. mcDuffies    3    1       3       2
10. Pimpette    0    2       1       4
11. Kwill       0    2       1       4
12. MandM       0    1       0       4

So, first round is a bit sparse, but the most guessed entries are Eve's #1 (I guess the girl looks too much like Eve), IVstudio's #6 and my Cope-styled #9. However, noone guessed Wendybird's realistic style and my Claud-like entry. Also noone guessed trhee belated entries, though most of people didn't try them until the next round.

In second round, most guessed entries were again Eve's #1, and IV's, but this time #2. Close behind them IV's other entry, Liberty Cabbage's entry, following them Kwill's girl and my "Cope".
Noone guessed my #7, Wendybird's #5 and M&M's entry. My entry was attributed either to Claude (heh heh) or to LC, and Wendy's entry was constantly applied to Eve. Two other belated entries, Pimpette's and Kwill's, fared solid, and so did the other Wendybird's entry.

[IVstudios]

Dudum! Results:
...
2. IVstudios
...
6. IVstudios
...

...
2. IV studios. The digital style of lines is similar to what he usually does, plus there's stuff I'll be explaining later on.
...
6. IV studios. As with 2, except this one is his style. If he hadn't used the same beige and orange tone for the second one, I'd be less convinced. Even if it wasn't him, I'm certain that 2 and 6 are done by the same person.
...

Ahahaha! Not even your tricksy use of different file types could fool me! >=D

Oh yeah? well your semi-gloating noncommittal

3. Style looks like Komi's, which should be an indicator that it probably isn't...

Gave you away for round 2. So nyaa!