New favorite character poll

For discussion of the comic, characters, criticisms, etc. and just dicussion in general.

Favorite character now?

Emma Gordon
1
14%
Theo Logan
1
14%
Will Jameson
2
29%
Alicey Frey
0
No votes
Brody McEwin
1
14%
Jeremiah Eans
0
No votes
Marissa Hannidy
0
No votes
Keslar
2
29%
 
Total votes : 7

New favorite character poll

Postby Miruku on Tue Feb 20, 2007 7:46 pm

Because the old one was from, like, page 50 or something..and now it's, like, page 145, and doesn't have a couple of characters. Leaving the other one up because I got lots of informative responses on it.

I'd be extremely intrigued if anyone chose Marissa or Jeremiah, but I figured I should put them down anyway. And, of course, the cat stays on the list. He's very important. I've heard theories!

Mostly, I figured Brody should be on there.

Anyway, leave an opinion if you want.
Image
Emma; music, drama, romance & slice-of-life
User avatar
Miruku
Regular Poster
 
Posts: 129
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 10:33 pm

Postby Miruku on Mon Mar 12, 2007 10:11 am

Nice. One vote for the cat.
Image
Emma; music, drama, romance & slice-of-life
User avatar
Miruku
Regular Poster
 
Posts: 129
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 10:33 pm

Postby Thisberichard on Sun Mar 18, 2007 11:37 pm

It's a lot harder to choose now.

I've really taken to Will, and while she faltered in my book for a while, Emma's reclaimed her former position and advanced it.
I even like Theo now, thanks in large part to the girly porn issue. ^_^
And Brody... hrmf.

I'm going with Will, but it's a -narrow- win.
Meh Comic: <a href="http://www.drunkduck.com/Stairway_From_Heaven">Stairway From Heaven</a>
User avatar
Thisberichard
Newbie
 
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 6:02 am
Location: Bethesda, MD

Postby Miruku on Mon Mar 19, 2007 7:06 am

Ah, Will. He's grown so much from his plot device purposes.
Emma faltering from the crown of glory, hmmm? Did she do anything in particular to temporarily lose your favor? She IS kind of a bitch sometimes, I gotta say.

Does "hrmpf" mean something along the lines of "pshaw" or "whatever"? He's very popular with the ladies, you know.
It's kind of weird how we all flock to scruffy middle aged men...that's why "House" is so popular!
Image
Emma; music, drama, romance & slice-of-life
User avatar
Miruku
Regular Poster
 
Posts: 129
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 10:33 pm

Postby Thisberichard on Mon Mar 19, 2007 7:23 am

There wasn't anything in particular that Emma did, I don't think... it was mostly that, for a while, she'd gotten a little dull. Too predictable, maybe. But she's better now, as I said, even than she'd been before.
I have no problem with her bitchitude whatsoever.

And the "hrmf" was a "hrmf" of thought and consideration. Though I can see how it might have seemed otherwise.
Meh Comic: <a href="http://www.drunkduck.com/Stairway_From_Heaven">Stairway From Heaven</a>
User avatar
Thisberichard
Newbie
 
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 6:02 am
Location: Bethesda, MD

Postby Miruku on Mon Mar 19, 2007 9:40 am

Alrighty. Good to know.
Out of curiosity, as you seem to have somewhat strong feelings on the subject, any particular reason you generally dislike Theo?

Your opinions are fascinating me at the moment, as you actually have some...also, I don't want to do my homework and would like to continue wasting time on my computer.
Image
Emma; music, drama, romance & slice-of-life
User avatar
Miruku
Regular Poster
 
Posts: 129
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 10:33 pm

Postby Thisberichard on Mon Mar 19, 2007 10:41 am

Avoidance and procrastination are my two most common pastimes.

I don't hugely dislike Theo. Not so much anymore, at any rate. But I dislike him as a romantic interest, at least. Before the romance novel thing, he seemed like a sort of self-centered emo kid, really. I mean, exceptions made for friends, but usually overexpectant and without a whole lot of depth more than his generally negative attitude.

Now, there's nothing wrong with a disagreeable character, especially if it's something they're meant to grow out of. I think the main point is that it seemed like there was nothing -more- to him.

And that's mitigated, I think, to a degree by the romance novel thing. It says something about him beyond the way he behaves around other people. About who he is in private. We get that sort of automatically with other characters (like Will) whose attitude towards others conveys a lot more about them.

I used to look at Theo like I looked at Kaoru from Kenshin:
"Why do they keep using her? There is no depth of character. She exists almost entirely as a foil for others, but they keep trying to make her an important character. I wish they'd cut that out."
Now, it wasn't entirely like that -- Theo -did- have a personality, after all -- but it was similar. The difference is even greater now, since you've given the character some depth.

But I still dislike Theo for Emma, even with that new depth.
It's not really about the way their personalities clash -- though that might be a small issue, I don't know -- but it's mostly about the fact that they don't really bring anything new out of each other. They generally act the same way with or without the other. I mean, when they meet it affects how they feel about the other, but it doesn't really change their approach to things. They don't affect each other on a deeper level.

I'm not going to say "Will and Emma should hook up!" but I'll look at them just for the comparison.
Will's general mood and behavior doesn't change a whole lot around Emma. Certainly not as much as Theo's. But there's something more subtle, with greater depth. You can feel the relationship driving them to evolve, just a little. Even as their attitudes toward the other stay the same, their attitudes towards the rest of the world change ever so slightly.

A good relationship, in a story, is one that does more for the characters than change or determine the relationship between the characters. And while that's not exclusive to romance, it's more important there than in other places.

That's not to say that a relationship can't stand alone, but it needs to be particularly compelling and not somethning meant to make readers think about where the story is going. It can't be vital to the story, because it's something of a non sequitor. Maybe an -awesome- non sequitor, but it doesn't really work work as a central piece of the story.


Right. So this (really wordy) explanation isn't a good one, and I'm not satisfied with it. But it's the best I can do right now. If it sounds stupid, I apologize -- I assure you it doesn't convey my feelings and their reasons very well. If it sounds really smart, that's still worth noting, I think.
Meh Comic: <a href="http://www.drunkduck.com/Stairway_From_Heaven">Stairway From Heaven</a>
User avatar
Thisberichard
Newbie
 
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 6:02 am
Location: Bethesda, MD

Postby Miruku on Mon Mar 19, 2007 2:48 pm

Holy crap! I think you might have put more thought into this than I have.
Curse you for making me rethink things!
You are right, though, not much has happened in regards to Theo's character so far. That is intended for part 2 (starting after chapter 8, which I've almost finished...so, let's say page....180...ish?). But now I'm thinking about it, though I've intended to wait to flesh him out until after Emma is a fairly solid character, I haven't really thought about Theo's character in a while and I don't really know how to portray him well.

A sudden realization; he is so much like me, that I haven't bothered to think about his character because I know it so well...which leads to the accidental assumption that everyone else gets him like I do. Like, I'm kind of a grumpy jerk unless I'm trying really hard or I'm around people I'm comfortable with, and that's pretty much exactly what he does (this was an accidental likeness, btw).

The relationship issue is something I've never thought about. I've never been in a romantic relationship, and I kind of think like a guy in regards to other peoples' relationships (ie if you like them, you like them, if you want to be/stay with them and there are no obstacles barring your path, then please do and stop whining about how you're not sure if they're "the one"). I guess the only romantic relationships I'm around a lot are my roommate and her boyfriend, and my parents. Both pairs being a little odd and mismatched, but generally awesome.

So now I'm rethinking things, because of what you said. I'm glad, though. This is why I never let myself set anything in stone more than a chapter ahead. Just outlines. Outlines can be changed or elaborated upon.

And this is why I love feedback! Yay!

Most of that also probably didn't make much sense, but I just had to watch a bunch of ballet so...my mind has been numbed.

EDIT: Ooh! I knew I forgot something; I was gonna say, as a comparison, (if you watch Lost...) that the relationships between the three (not the characters, of course) are like Jack, Kate, and Sawyer. Kate has feelings for both of them, but with Jack it's more because she knows he's a good man, while with Sawyer it's because she's just naturally drawn to him.
It doesn't fit exactly, but that's what it made me think of.
Image
Emma; music, drama, romance & slice-of-life
User avatar
Miruku
Regular Poster
 
Posts: 129
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 10:33 pm

Postby Corkydork on Sat Jun 16, 2007 1:52 am

I generally like Theo most, I mostly like jerky characters, they just bring a dopey grin to my face.

Though for some reason I do have a slight dislike for Emma, not a "holy crap DIE!" burning hatred just a little "Oh it's you." which pops up every so often.

I have to say I don't mind who ends up splunking who, I get warm and fuzzy inside whenever anyone ends up together.
User avatar
Corkydork
Newbie
 
Posts: 6
Joined: Sat Jun 16, 2007 12:37 am
Location: UK

Postby Aureolus on Sun Jun 24, 2007 3:52 pm

Keslar, because i just love the feline that comforts the main character x3
User avatar
Aureolus
Regular Poster
 
Posts: 46
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 7:45 am

lfwjbt wpoynj

Postby Taspsanny on Wed Feb 29, 2012 10:29 pm

matematyka wokol nas 2 zbior zadan odpowiedzi how to play heroes 2 on samsung druk kp do wydrukowania gta iv na telefon symbian kiedy sie zakocham 94 streszczenie iak dodac mape pro farm 1 2011 pl chomik matrura explorer odpowiedzi pelnometrazowe filmy porno ranking saints row 3 nie dziala saywow sprawdzian puls zycia ewolucja zycia nowa era navidrive rt3 spb shell 3d android cracked neo v rar igo primo europe 2011 torrent cwiczeniowka exam challenges 3 module 3 english explorer 1 test 5 pobierz za darmo cd key do battlefield 3 agrar simulator 2012klucz unite 6 str 54 kalendarz ckm 2012 do obejzenia miami nights 2 pl na kompa samsung 5500 led funkcja demo jak zrobic mod na belarke do ls 11 lista starogard gdanski bony sodexo crack football manager 2011 darmowe key serial nod32 gran turismo 5 pc download chomikuj jak zmniejszyc recoil steam 2011 proste hacki na swiat wg zombie kiedy sie zakocham streszczenie od odcinka 102 auto mapa na symbiana 2011 swiat wedlug kiepskich chomikuj 2012 sprawdzian z can crack mw3 multiplajer mpc forum Szymona Holownie ksiazki online sabotaz honey download djoles angry birds htc hd 2 dlownload pobierz wwe raw 2010 za darmo gran turismo 5 pc download chomikuj 3 samorzadna rzeczpospolita wos npp mod karmienia krow ls 2011 test z podrecznika wos rozdzial 2 gry na avile chomikuj do pobrania za darmo basia mularczyk chomikuj ebook jutro 5 john kody do skyrim 5 na itemy wiejski zycie angielskie na gry pl wp skrypty darkorbit 2012 knr wacetob promocje orange na karte need for speed world jak najszybciej zarobic nokia c5 jak wylaczyc buzki wsip probny egzamin 2012 gimnazjalny rebus rozmiar Gry naruto na teledon gothic 2 noc kruka kody torrenty org gghack download free doktor oz radzi do sciagniecia matrix lektor bluray torrent mod wozu konnego do ls 2011 m jak milosc odc 882 streszczenie testy na prawo jazdy 2011 java peb rns 300 wgrywanie polskiego menu praca domowa z angielskiego cwiczenia str 36 zad 1 pobierz film szybcy i wsciekli 5 z peb pl graj za darmo minecraft wiki mabilne playgg na nokie c3 00 Gieta na telefon pobierz pes 2012 na pc pelna wersja download po polsku angry birds htc hd 2 dlownload odp do spr z chemi poznajemy kwasy kl 2 chomikuj streszczenie telenoweli tryumf milosci norweski szybki start (pc) warez zadanie z zeszytu cwiczen kompass strona 4 pobierz rytual cwiczenia z chemii nowa era 3 strona 52 53 55 k800i motyw z dzwonkiem promocja na grzyby do sf game sim lock my700x zegarek na telefon sony ericsson za darmo planeta nowa klasa 1 str 37 zad 5 samsung gt e1150 jak wgrac piosenke gry na androida chomikuj pes 12 jak wgrywac decor cad paradyz sciagnac streszczenie w pustyni i w puszczy tomu 2 blad fifa 12 config exe chomikuj noc rekinow lektor hd darmowe pobierz gre ihf handball challenge12 mapy sony ericsson xperia soft nokia 500 adobe flash player na nokie do pobrania za free teledyski chomikuj amv deluxe ski jump 4 full version cd key notatki z lekcji historii klasa 6 chomikuj tapety na telefon z elitemt2 nfs the run blad d3dcompiler_43 dll filmik samsung galaxy s2opinie faraon na win 7 chomikuj pl lt3 chomikuj nie pasuje tutaj little beaver pobierz za darmo samsung gt3530 aplikacje diamenty 2 pobierz gra na telefon samsung talking tom 2 www gra fineasz i ferb podrusz w drugim wymiaze pl wklejki na sledzika testy gwo historia download
Taspsanny
Newbie
 
Posts: 1
Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 10:27 pm


 

Return to Emma



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest