My point is that Civilizations and Cultures are not people, any more than a Corporation is. They do not have Inalienable Rights. Civilizations and cultures are <I>artificial constructs used by people</i> to interact with one another and with outside cultures. They are as artificial and possess no more innate "right to exist" than any other artificial social contract. <I>Only the people within the society have any rights, and their interests hold superior status. If the culture violates those rights, then the culture must give way.</i>
http://www.shivae.org/csafari/archive.php?day=20010712
I have to say that this writer's approach to the prime directive has its own terrible flaw....
because it boils down to nothing more than an intergalactic version of <I>GUN CONTROL.</i>
Consider: What can we infer from this strip, and the one immediately following it?
1)The alien race in question-- I'll call them "Shivaeans" to save space--- has sufficient military force to enforce its rather hypocritical "no violence" statute on other nations and worlds with impunity. That implies an incredible amount of military muscle.
2)However, the existence of such a level of military force also indicates that they are not the only interstellar civilization out there... that there are civilizations and entities out there hostile enough, and powerful enough, to present a palpable threat to the "Shivaeans".
5)That if these other entities are a sufficient threat to the Shivaeans, then they are definitely a threat to "primitive" little earth.
6)Moreover, if the Shivaeans have enemies that threaten them, they cannot be ignorant of the reality of "the barbarians at the gate." They have to be aware, by brute experience, that even a peaceful, advanced society needs to be able to wield force to defend itself against those who only understand force... and that the barbarians come in all sizes, from planet-spanning empires to tinpot banana republics to vicious little street punks.
7)Furthermore, they have to be aware---from brutal experience--- of the truth of "peace through superior firepower." If they are truly as enlightened as they think, they are enlightened to the truth that the violent and lawless attack where they see weakness, <I>and that the surest way to prevent violence and war is to be too strong to be attacked with impunity.</i>
8)<B>Yet they effectively deny other races the right to defend themselves, by denying them the right to produce weapons of war sufficient to the threats that the Shivaeans themselves are armed against.</b> They keep other nations comparitively weak and vulnerable, and therefore dependent upon the Shivaeans.... and a constant temptation to the truly violent.<I>They provoke the very carnage they wish to prevent, by making the peoples subject to them into prey.</i>
They behave as a latter day British Empire.... they have marched into India, handed out their beads and bangles, and then proclaimed that no native Indian may carry a gun.